Cuomo wields veto pen to strike $1.5M allocation from budget
By Chris Churchill, Times Union Business
writer
Published 12:00 a.m., Thursday, April 14, 2011
ALBANY - Gov.
Andrew Cuomo has vetoed money for foreclosure prevention
services, shocking housing advocates who say the funding
is crucial for helping at-risk homeowners.
Housing advocates had hoped for as much as $15 million
in state funding for the Foreclosure Prevention Services
Program. Cuomo, who has won praise for working to
control state spending, this week nixed $1.5 million
placed in the $132.5 billion budget by the Democrats in
control of the Assembly.
That move has housing groups scrambling to line up new
funding sources. But they fear they'll have to turn away
homeowners in dire need of assistance.
"It's hard to say to people, 'We can't help you
anymore,'" said Louise McNeilly, coordinator of the
Capital Region's HomeSave Coalition. "This is a big
hit."
New York's foreclosure prevention laws are generally
considered among the nation's toughest, requiring that
lenders take several time-consuming steps before moving
ahead with a foreclosure.
Among those steps is a 90-day pre-foreclosure notice
that warns homeowners and puts them in touch with groups
like HomeSave, whose counselors work with lenders to get
the troubled owners back on track.
But the elimination of foreclosure funding threatens to
undercut the effort and the state's own law, advocates
say.
"Unless we're able to find alternative sources of
funding, housing counseling and legal assistance
agencies are probably going to close and lay people
off," said Kirsten Keefe, an attorney at the nonprofit
Empire Justice Center in Albany.
Foreclosure prevention services did not receive money in
the prior state budget, because they were still using
pools of funds appropriated in earlier years. That led
Cuomo to veto $1.5 million in the newest budget as new
spending.
The governor wrote: "This item passed by the
Legislature, to which I object and do not approve, is a
new appropriation, but is improperly characterized as a
re-appropriation.
"Accordingly, this item is disapproved."
Cuomo's office did not reply Wednesday to a request for
comment. The reaction by housing groups to Cuomo's veto
echoes that from some education and social service
advocates, who have decried the budget as harmful to the
less fortunate. Business and taxpayer groups, however,
have generally praised the budget.
In some respects, New York's anti-foreclosure efforts
may be victims of success. The state, along with the
Capital Region, is generally thought to have declining
and lower-than-average foreclosure rates.
A new report by RealtyTrac, a California company that
monitors the distressed housing market, illustrates the
point, finding the number of foreclosure filings
statewide was down 32.1 percent in the first quarter,
when compared to the prior year.
In the Capital Region, the number of filings was down
16.8 percent during the first quarter, though they rose
by 66.4 percent for the month of March alone, compared
to the prior year.
But counselors say declining numbers are misleading,
because the state's chief judge last year imposed rules
requiring the verification of all foreclosure paperwork.
That move, they say, has created a backlog of filings
that are nevertheless still in the pipeline.
"Eventually, that logjam is going to be released," Keefe
said.
Counselors also note that the number of pre-foreclosure
notices sent to homeowners in the region has not tapered
off in recent months. (See chart.)
"There are still significant numbers of people in the
community who are at risk," McNeilly said.
